I have been doing this for 51 years I have heard all of these paradigms before.
I can tell you this. People who don’t gamble have been “cleaning up pool” since I started playing.
Since I was 14 I played pool for money. I loved pool but when I found out you could win money playing, it changed my attitude completely.
I went to the pool room to make money. I traveled America to make money. The pool subculture was a self-perpetuating economic engine that needed poolrooms to survive so it makes sense that pool rooms could not survive without them.
You would see many great playing (outsiders) men with jobs come in to test their mettle. Time and again they were sent home late, broke—only to have to get up early again and show up on time for a couple of weeks work to get their money back. Then many would try it again. There were many ways to keep them coming back (another story).
But when these men got married that was the end of them on the field of honor.
Then the rains came—I am sorry I mean the leagues. Now these fun players had a venue to show their skills, where the outcome had no consequence on their economic relationship to society. For five, 10, maybe 15 games a week they could be heroes.
They never had to go home and tell their wives to sign the title to the Jag because the player on the porch is the new owner, and if they played “really good” they could go to Vegas once or twice a year and spend, lose or donate all of the money in or to the Casinos that normally, without the leagues, would have gone into the “pool subculture.”
You guys can talk all you want, for the real player, pool is a blood sport. At the beginning of this century there was only pool and boxing—nothing else. The pool rooms were full at one time. In downtown Chicago there were over 400 pool rooms (not table’s pool rooms) where men—mostly bachelors—contended with men.
Today “real” players in America (not the rest of the world) have become the “mascots” of the well-intended sponsors, promoters, backers and wanna be’s.
So the leagues have been the conduit to remove the resources from and destroy the economy of the pool rooms and vest those resources in a little town in the desert and various Indian reservations scattered throughout the land.
That money never returns to the pool economy, it is gone forever. “Honey I did lose everything budgeted for Las Vegas” is the new battle cry, not “I just lost the Jag to that uneducated bum looking guy on the front porch.”
If all of this is true, it would mean that pool rooms all over America would be closing.
But wait there is more! Pool rooms all over America are closing.
They are driven out of business as the fuel of their industry is deposited in the coffers of those that only book bets, but do not make them.
In all of these years I have seen a lot of “promoters” come and go with the same battle cry. “We have to clean up our sport!”
And the cleaner it has become the fewer pool rooms there are and the harder it is to find those promoters.